Independent hockey journal · NHL, realignment, books and fan cultureReader-supported · no paid placements

Home › NHL Realignment Project

Nate Silver Optimizes the NHL, Then I Redraw It

NHL Realignment Project · updated
Nate Silver Optimizes the NHL, Then I Redraw It

In his NY Times post, FiveThirtyEight's Nate Silver steps away from politics and baseball to take on the NHL. The post's title, "Why Can't Canada Win the Stanley Cup?" is a lead-in premise to his re-imagining of a more balanced league in terms of where and how intense fanbases seem to be.

It's nice to see a mind far smarter and more analytical than my feeble patchwork of five or six braincells look at how to better the league.

The Two Rules That Still Apply

I've taken his new 28-team optimized NHL and put my ol' realignment spin on it. Same guidelines apply as my NHL Realignment Project:

  • Keep the conferences limited to one or two time zones, which limits east-west travel
  • Preserve rivalries as much as logistically possible

Four Conferences, No Divisions

Silver lands on 28 teams. The redraw puts them in four conferences without divisions, which is the shape the project kept coming back to.

Bonus Tidbits

  • I've used the four conference, no divisions format
  • The conferences bring back the old school names used for divisions from 1974-1993
  • The new Dallas Stars logo is used
  • Quebec Nordiques, Hamilton Tigers, Montreal Maroons are all throwback names to previous NHL teams located in each of those locales.
  • Seattle Metropolitans, while never an NHL team, was a PCHA team that played from 1915-1924, and was the first American team to win the Stanley Cup (wikipedia article)
  • Toronto Legacy is a name used by a movement for getting a team into Markham, Ontario (site).

Nice to post something about realignment again. I gotta say, I missed it.

Read it for the hockey. This journal explains how the sport works; it does not predict results and does not sell anything. Where a number is not publicly checkable we say so instead of inventing one.

Read next

NHL Realignment Project

What Realignment Means for a League and Its Fans

Moving teams between conferences and divisions looks like a map exercise, but the promise and the cost land on rivalries, travel and the playoff path.

NHL Realignment Project

Conferences and Divisions: How They Shape a Season

Grouping decides the schedule, the playoff path and how often rivals meet. What conferences and divisions actually control, and why fans argue about them.

NHL Realignment Project

Travel, Time Zones and the NHL Schedule Debate

Distance is the easy part. Time zones change the body clock, which is why a genuinely fair schedule is harder to build than it looks on a map.