Independent hockey journal · NHL, realignment, books and fan cultureReader-supported · no paid placements

Home › Hockey

NHL Playoff Format: Four Divisions, Top Four Qualify

Hockey · updated
NHL Playoff Format: Four Divisions, Top Four Qualify

Just for the record, and despite all my NHL realignment shenanigans, I do have a single opinion and stance on how the NHL should operate once they realign in 2012. My crazy options all apply once the NHL decides to relocate any franchise or realign yet again.

This is not one of the weekly scenarios. It is the fixed position underneath all of them, the version I would sign off on if the league ever asked.

The Shape of the League

  • There should be four divisions of 7 or 8 teams each.
  • Detroit, and even Columbus, should move to the Eastern Conference.
  • The top four teams in each division should qualify for the playoffs.

How the Rounds Work

  1. The first two rounds of the playoffs determine the Division Champions.
  2. The third round is between Division Champions and determines the Conference Champions.
  3. The final round is between Conference Champions and determines the Stanley Cup Champions.
RoundWhat it decides
First two roundsDivision Champions
Third roundConference Champions
Final roundStanley Cup Champions

To Anyone Complaining About Eighth Place

Any team that finishes fifth, sixth, seventh or eighth in their division and complains about "having a better record than a playoff qualifier in another division" should get over it, shut up, and be thankful they are not in college football.

Why It Is Better

Divisional games and rivalries will get even more intense and hockey will be at least a little bit different than basketball, a very good thing. That is all. Just wanted to make it clear.

Read it for the hockey. This journal explains how the sport works; it does not predict results and does not sell anything. Where a number is not publicly checkable we say so instead of inventing one.

Read next

Hockey

How an NHL Season Is Structured, Part by Part

Preseason roster sorting, the long regular season, the trade deadline and a playoff format that plays like a different sport, explained part by part.

Hockey

Reading NHL Standings: Points and Games in Hand

What points actually reward, why games in hand confuse everyone, which tie-breakers decide seasons, and three ways to read the same table calmly.

Hockey

What a Goaltender Actually Does Between the Pipes

Positioning before reflexes, reading the play rather than the puck, and the routine that holds a goaltender together across a long, uneven season.